How to Choose an SEO Company for Your Business

14 March, 2024
Chloe Baird
8min read


  • What is SEO?
  • How to Choose the Right SEO Company
  • Evaluating Potential SEO Companies
  • What to Expect From an SEO Agency
  • Making your Decision

In today's digital landscape, the visibility of your business online can make a significant difference in its success. But how do you make sure your business’s website is actually seen by your target audience? That’s where SEO comes in. 

What is SEO?

Search engine optimisation (SEO) is a methodology employed to improve a website's visibility on search engines like Google and Bing. By optimising your site's content, structure, and on-page elements like keywords and meta tags, SEO makes it easier for search engines to ‘crawl’ your website. By crawling the website, they glean the relevant information to rank your site in search results.

The easier your site is to crawl, the easier it is for search engines to find relevant, high-quality content. And the better content you have on your site, the higher the chance your pages will rank well on the search engine result pages. 

Why Your Business Needs SEO

Should I hire an SEO company? If you want to boost your organic traffic, increase user engagement, and drive conversions then the answer is yes. No matter how large or small your business, an SEO agency can help build an impactful SEO strategy or strengthen and expand on your existing strategy.

Effective SEO is the backbone of any good marketing strategy. Firstly, it significantly increases your website traffic by ensuring your site appears higher in search engine results for relevant queries. This increased exposure leads to better quality leads; individuals who find your site through search engines are often looking for solutions that your business offers, making them more likely to convert into customers. Plus, high rankings in search results enhance your brand's credibility and awareness, as users tend to trust sites that appear on the first page of their search results.

SEO is a Long-term Strategy

Unlike paid advertising campaigns that offer short-term results, SEO is a long-term marketing strategy. Its effects accumulate over time, with the potential to provide sustained traffic growth and brand visibility.

Part of the reason here is because search engine algorithms are constantly being updated. On top of this, no one actually knows what the algorithms are searching for—we just have clues and tips from the search engine companies themselves about what ranks well and what doesn’t. This means that SEO specialists are continuously working to keep up to date with the latest trends and updates to ensure that the websites they manage don’t lose their top-spot rankings. It’s a full-time job that requires a firm grasp of SEO best practices as well as a well-rounded knowledge of new and evolving developments.

So, while SEO is something you need to consistently manage, review and invest in, it does provide you with a host of benefits, such as boosting your online presence and maximising your organic traffic, which drives long-term results.

How to Choose the Right SEO Company

The right SEO company can help you achieve your digital marketing goals by applying tactics and strategies that align with your business needs. But how do you make sure the SEO agency you choose is the right fit for you?

Knowing Your SEO Goals

First off, you need to understand what you aim to achieve through SEO. You can capitalise on SEO practices to help promote a number of areas, including:

  • Increasing brand awareness.

  • Driving sales. 

  • Improving website traffic. 

  • Enhancing user engagement. 

  • Increasing the trustworthiness and credibility of your brand. 

Having clear goals helps you find an SEO service provider that can tailor their strategies to meet your specific needs. This clarity ensures a more focused approach and, ultimately, better results.

What to Look for in an SEO Agency

When considering SEO agencies, transparency, experience, and a tailored approach are considered the top key qualities. The best SEO companies will be open about their methodologies, provide SEO case studies that demonstrate their success, and have extensive experience in handling various SEO challenges.

However, the ultimate consideration you need to look out for is a tailored approach. Any good SEO agency can devise a solid SEO strategy. But what takes an SEO company from good to great is their ability to thoroughly understand and adapt to their various clients’ needs. Instead of a one-size-fits-all solution, the SEO company you ultimately choose to partner with should be able to mould its SEO strategy to align with your unique business objectives. They will champion collaboration through a consultative approach and go the extra mile when it comes to understanding your business needs, goals and audience.

Questions to Ask When Hiring an SEO Company

To ensure you're choosing the right SEO company, it's essential to ask the right questions. By carefully considering these factors, you can confidently navigate how to choose an SEO company that aligns with your business goals and is equipped to drive meaningful results.

If you’ve found a good SEO company and are considering partnering with them, here are a few questions you can put to them:

  • What experience do you have with businesses in the same industry as mine?

  • How do you approach overcoming SEO challenges that might arise?

  • What strategies do you employ to understand your clients’ target audience and market?

  • How do you integrate your SEO efforts with other digital marketing strategies, such as paid media?

  • Can you explain how you measure the success of your SEO campaigns?

  • Could you provide details about your team's expertise in SEO?

  • Do you have any SEO case studies or success stories that you can share?

  • How do you stay updated with search engines’ evolving algorithms?

  • Can you describe your communication and reporting process to ensure I'm informed about the progress of my SEO campaign?

Evaluating Potential SEO Companies

What makes a good SEO company, and how can you make sure you’re choosing an agency that aligns with your business needs, values and goals? Choosing the right SEO partner is crucial for enhancing your online presence and achieving your business goals. 

SEO Case Studies and Success Stories

SEO case studies and success stories are invaluable resources when assessing potential SEO agencies. They provide concrete evidence of an agency's ability to deliver tangible results and navigate the complexities of search engine optimisation. By examining these SEO case studies, you can gain insights into the types of businesses the agency has worked with, the challenges they've overcome, and the outcomes they've achieved. 

Understanding Their SEO Strategies

The strategic approach of an SEO company is another essential aspect for you to consider. When you’re first assessing your potential SEO partner, you need to gain a detailed understanding of just how they plan to achieve your SEO goals and how they’ll customise their strategies to fit your business needs.

Most SEO agencies will first conduct a thorough initial assessment, such as site audits, to identify any and all opportunities for optimisation, and develop a comprehensive strategy around this that also aligns with your objectives. A personalised approach like this ensures that the SEO services provided are not only effective, but relevant to your specific market, industry and audience. 

What to Expect From an SEO Agency

Setting the right expectations from the start of your partnership with an SEO agency is key to a successful collaboration. 

Initial Assessments and Strategies

In the initial stages of your partnership, you can expect a comprehensive assessment of your website’s current SEO standing, including detailed site audits and strategy development. These first steps are crucial for identifying both strengths and areas for improvement. An SEO services provider will use this information to develop and hone a customised strategy that targets your specific goals, whether it's improving your site's ranking on search engine results pages, increasing organic traffic, or enhancing user engagement. By laying the foundational groundwork in this way, it will set your website up for success in all future SEO efforts. 

Ongoing Communication and Reporting

Ongoing communication and transparent reporting are vital components of a successful partnership with an SEO agency. Regular updates and reports not only keep you informed about the progress of your SEO campaign but also build trust between your business and the SEO service provider. These reports should detail the strategies employed, the results achieved, and the next steps in your SEO journey.

Transparency in reporting ensures that you’re always aware of where you stand in terms of achieving your SEO goals and allows for timely adjustments to the strategy as needed. This commitment to open communication and detailed reporting is what you should expect from a top-tier SEO agency that is focused on building, maintaining and growing their valuable client relationships.

Making your Decision

After evaluating potential SEO companies, understanding their strategies, and setting your expectations, it's time to make a decision. 

Final Considerations

From your list, you’ve now managed to narrow down your top picks for an SEO agency to partner with. Before finalising your number one choice, it's essential to consider not just the cost, but other benefits your SEO agency can bring: 

  1. Value: SEO budget is a significant factor. However, choosing an SEO agency based solely on price can be misleading. SEO costs can vary depending on a lot of different factors. So make sure you evaluate the value they offer compared to their price.

  2. Compatibility:  The best SEO company for your business should not only understand your industry but also share your vision for growth and success. They should be a perfect match in terms of understanding your goals, objectives and needs. 

  3. Long-term growth: Lastly, consider the potential for a long-term partnership. SEO is not a one-off task but a continuous process that requires critical attention and effort to maintain. Selecting an agency that you can work with over the long term is beneficial for maintaining a consistent and evolving SEO strategy, as well as a strong relationship. 

Decision Time

Armed with the knowledge of what to look for in an SEO agency, what to expect, and the questions to ask when hiring an SEO company, you’re now equipped to make an informed decision.

Making the final decision can be tricky—especially if you’re trying to choose between multiple agencies who have all delivered convincing pitches. Choose the right SEO agency that aligns with your business goals, offers transparency, and demonstrates a proven track record through SEO case studies.

At G Squared, we’re proud to offer an extensive range of SEO marketing services that can best serve your business. We take the time to understand your business, goals, needs and target audience to execute SEO strategies that will drive results.

We also offer comprehensive web development and paid media services. This gives us the ability to provide an integrated service to our clients that covers these three crucial aspects of online digital marketing.

We’re your local SEO agency, located in the heart of Sydney, though we partner with clients from all over Australia. If you’d like to get in touch with us about how we can help your business grow, reach out to us today.

Our awards.

More brands that we’ve helped.

Featured insights from our team.

Get in touch.

We’d love to hear what you’re up to and how we can help.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.